Identities Are Changeable (Miel Music)
Released November 2015
Grammy Nominee for Best Latin Jazz Album 2016
and composer Miguel Zenón asked his friends the question he had been asking
himself: What does it mean to be Puerto Rican in 21st-century New York
That was the point of departure for Identities Are Changeable, the startlingly original album by Zenón, who grew up in the island’s main city of San Juan and came to New York in 1998 to pursue a career in music.
Zenón’s experience of moving via the air bridge from the small Antillean island to the landing strip 1600 miles north is something he shares with hundreds of thousands of other “Puerto Rican-New Yorkers.” Puerto Ricans are not immigrants in the United States: for nearly a century – since 1917 – Puerto Ricans have, unlike other natives of Latin America, been US citizens, able to come and go as they please between the island of Puerto Rico and the mainland. When they come north, overwhelmingly they go to New York City. After different waves of migration over the decades – most numerously in the 1950s – about 1.2 million “Puerto Rican-Americans” were living in the greater New York area as of 2012. Miguel Zenón has become one of jazz’s most original thinkers. Today, at the age of 37, he’s one of the best-known alto saxophonists in jazz. The quartet he leads has been working together for more than ten years, building its ensemble coherence on stages all over the world. But Zenón’s more than a great musician and bandleader. One of only a handful of jazz musicians to be chosen for the coveted MacArthur fellowships (in 2008), he’s at the forefront of a new movement that in recent years has brought the composer to a new prominence in jazz. But beyond his facility at writing and playing music, there is a great intellectual subject at the center of Miguel Zenón’s artistic world: the complexity of Puerto Rican culture. Beginning with his third album as a leader, Jíbaro (2005), and continuing with Esta Plena (2009) and Alma Adentro: The Puerto Rican Songbook (2011) (both Grammy-nominated), and Oye!!! Live In Puerto Rico (2013), Miguel Zenón has created a series of thoughtfully framed works that interpret different facets of Puerto Rican culture. Zenón’s Puerto Rico is a bit like Gabriel García Márquez’s Colombia or Gilberto Gil’s Brazil: the highly focused center of an imaginative universe that looks to the world while being rooted at home. It serves a springboard for his personal style: no one else’s Puerto Rico – and no one else’s jazz – sounds like Miguel Zenón’s. Identities Are Changeable, Zenón’s powerful new composition, is a song cycle for large ensemble, with his longtime quartet (Luis Perdomo, piano; Hans Glawischnig, bass; Henry Cole, drums) at the center, incorporating recorded voices from a series of interviews conducted by Zenón. Commissioned as a multimedia work by Montclair State University’s Peak Performances series, it has a multi-media element with audio and video footage from the interviews, complemented by a video installation created by artist David Dempewolf. It’s been performed at such prestigious venues as the New England Conservatory’s Jordan Hall in Boston, The SFJAZZ Center in San Francisco, and Zankel Hall in the Carnegie Hall complex in New York City. The album version of Identities Are Changeable is a labor of love, produced by Miguel Zenón without commercial backing. It will be released November 4, 2014 as only the second title on his personal label, Miel Music.
The core of Identities Are Changeable is a series of English-language interviews Miguel Zenón conducted with seven New Yorkers of Puerto Rican descent. His initial impetus for the project came from reading The Diaspora Strikes Back: Caribeño Tales of Learning and Turning, a book by cultural theorist Juan Flores based on interviews with Puerto Ricans who had returned to the island after living on the mainland. Zenón turned the tables and interviewed Flores, whose insightful commentary grounds Zenón’s finished work. Other interviewees who weave in and out of the musical texture are Miguel Zenón’s sister Patricia Zenón; the young musicians Luqués Curtis and Camilo Molina; actress Sonia Manzano; poet Bonafide Rojas; and family friend Alex Rodríguez. This is speech as music: their recorded voices, speaking off-the-cuff in their own surroundings with the sound of the city around them, tell the story. Writing about it in The Wall Street Journal, jazz journalist Larry Blumenfeld quoted Zenón: “I asked pretty much the same things to everyone,” [Zenón] said, “the essential question being ‘What does it mean to be Puerto Rican?'” As Mr. Zenón analyzed his footage, themes emerged: Do you speak English or Spanish? How is tradition passed on? Zenón identified key excerpts from the interviews and grouped them into six thematically related clusters: national identity, home, blackness, language, the next generation, and music. As he began writing instrumental music to support the voices, those clusters became six fully elaborated musical movements, plus an intro and outro, making for a 75-minute work of symphonic dimensions.
Identities Are Changeable showcases Miguel Zenón’s most ambitious instrumental writing yet. It’s scored for a 16-piece large ensemble, consisting of Zenón’s working quartet supplemented by five saxes, four trumpets, and three trombones. If you think you already know what that sounds like, think again: though this pulsating, percolating music is intensely rhythmic, it’s not achieved through the now traditional mambo-style section writing. It’s still Latin, and it’s still jazz, but this sonority – Zenón’s first big-band score – presents a different kind of compositional and orchestrational challenge, and a different kind of polyrhythm. It’s more like modern symphonic writing, with layered multiple meters that give new meaning to the term “harmonic rhythm” as they create a translucent texture. Zenón explains: “all of the compositions explore the idea of multiple rhythmic structures coexisting with each other (e.g., 5 against 7, 3 against 2, 5 against 3).” Drummer Henry Cole has his hands (and feet) full holding down the simultaneous time streams, as does Zenón when he conducts the group live. The players are a selected elite team – hear John Ellis’s tenor solo on “Same Fight,” or Tim Albright’s trombone feature on “First Language.” There’s no way to convey in words the impact of the orchestral effects, but reviewing the Zankel Hall performance for The New York Times, Ben Ratliff writes:
“[The] sound and language didn’t directly suggest traditional Puerto Rican music or traditional jazz. Its rhythm was phrased almost completely in stacked or odd meter, with parts of the band shifting into double or half time, and Mr. Zenón’s saxophone darting around the chord changes or resting on top, in long tones. There was drama and momentum in the music’s developing harmonic movement; at times a shift to a new chord felt like an event. All the music was deeply hybridized and original, complex but clear.”
It’s all at the service of Zenón’s relentless curiosity, as he writes in the album’s liner notes: When I first came into contact with Puerto Rican communities in this country, I was shocked to meet second and third generation Puerto Ricans who were as connected to the traditions of their parents/grandparents and as proud to be Puerto Rican as the people I knew back home. Where was this sense of pride coming from? What did they consider their first language? Their home? What did it mean to them to be Puerto Rican? What are the elements that help us shape our national identity? 4 If the music doesn’t directly answer these questions, it provides a way into thinking about them. Like Zenón’s other music, it’s about an entire society, but it’s deeply personal.
1. ¿De Dónde Vienes? (Overture) (Miguel Zenón) 4:26
2. Identities Are Changeable (Miguel Zenón) 11:47
3. My Home (Miguel Zenón) 11:26
4. Same Fight (Miguel Zenón) 12:24
5. First Language (Miguel Zenón) 12:29
6. Second Generation Lullaby (Miguel Zenón) 11:20
7. Through Culture And Tradition (Miguel Zenón) 10:30
8. ¿De Dónde Vienes? (Outro) (Miguel Zenón) 1:20
Miguel Zenón: alto saxophone
Luis Perdomo: piano
Hans Glawischnig: bass
Henry Cole: drums
“Identities” Big Band
Will Vinson: alto saxophone
Michael Thomas: alto saxophones
Samir Zarif: tenor saxophone
John Ellis (solo on “Same Fight”): tenor saxophone
Chris Cheek: baritone saxophone
Mat Jodrel: trumpet
Michael Rodriguez: trumpet
Alex Norris: trumpet
Jonathan Powell: trumpet
Ryan Keberle: trombone
Alan Ferber: trombone
Tim Albright (solo on “First Language”): trombone
Recorded March 18-19, 2014, at HR Studios, Frankfurt, Germany, and Systems Two, Brooklyn, NY
Producer: Miguel Zenon
It would simply be enough to just hear Miguel Zenón’s
saxophone; its fluid, darting, humming bird-like maneuvers, soulful and
piercing. Yet as one of the most distinctive altos in jazz,
the Grammy nominated and Guggenheim and MacArthur Fellow is also a
gifted composer who continues to deliver insights into his culture as vividly
expressed in 2011’s Alma Adentro: The Puerto Rican Songbook and 2009’s Esta
Plena, both released on Marsalis Music.
His ninth recording as a leader, Identities Are Changeable, is an ambitious project that finds Zenón with his longtime quartet (Luis Perdomo, piano; Hans Glawischnig, bass; Henry Cole, drums) and a large ensemble dubbed the Identities Big Band. The creative hook though is how the music is interwoven through a series of English-language interviews Miguel Zenón conducted with seven New Yorkers of Puerto Rican descent addressing what it means to be Puerto Rican in 21st-century New York City; questions that mirror Zenón’s own identity since he moved from San Juan to New York in 1998.
Commissioned as a multi-media work by Montclair State
University’s Peak Performances series, the album version combines music and
interviews into a brilliant program of jazz and dialog. The interviewees—who
include Zenón’s sister Patricia—make their introductions during the “¿De
Dónde Vienes?” amidst churning horns and a spirited tempo. During the
eight composition song cycle personal insights into the individual’s
backgrounds and aspirations emerge as the music colors its own narration.
Zenón’s brings a fresh stylistic approach as a composer marked by melodicism and intrepid charts communicated in the ebb and flow of “My Home” with its elegantly sweeping movement that culminate in a powerful cyclical horn pattern. “Same Fight” encompasses a swinging Harlemesque blues vibe with interviews speaking of the cultural commonalities between African Americans and Puerto Ricans within the city. Music highlights abound such as Glawischnig’s impressive bass solo in “Second Generation Lullaby” and the horn section’s tumultuous trades with Zenón’s serpentine solos. The charts give life to the interviewees’ comments moving through polyrhythmic changes and moods.
Thought-provoking interviews, memorable performances, and excellent composition, Zenón’s Identities Are Changeable has a distinct identity all its own.
Mark F. Turner (All About Jazz)